Environmental governance of a mass tourism destination: An analytic hierarchy process assessment of sustainable tourism policy implementation in Badung Regency, Bali, Indonesia

Alfi Haris Wanto, Thavia Aisyah Shinta Aprilla, Bambang Santoso Haryono, Eko Nurhaji Purnomo and Akhmad Amirudin
Vol 25, No 4, Oct 2026   |   DOI: 10.46488/NEPT.2027.v26i01.D1969   |   Pages: 73-83

Abstract

Badung Regency carries the heaviest tourism load in Indonesia, and with it some of the most serious environmental pressures at the destination scale. These include coastal solid waste, the conversion of agricultural land, and an exceedance of environmental carrying capacity that has not yet been measured. The problems have continued even after Regulation No. 9 of 2021 on Sustainable Tourism Destinations came into force, which suggests that the difficulty lies in how the policy is delivered rather than in the rules themselves. In this study we assessed how the regulation is implemented across its four sustainability pillars and measured the relative importance of the factors that govern delivery. A descriptive qualitative design was combined with the Analytic Hierarchy Process. The qualitative work used in-depth interviews with nine key informants, non-participant observation at Kuta and Seminyak beaches, and documentary analysis, while the Analytic Hierarchy Process broke the four Edwards III determinants into thirteen sub-criteria that were compared on the Saaty ninepoint scale and tested for consistency. Implementation was strongest in the socio-cultural and economic pillars and weakest in the environmental and governance pillars. The Analytic Hierarchy Process ranked communication first (0.399), followed by resources (0.266), bureaucratic structure (0.204), and disposition (0.131), with all consistency ratios below 0.10. Clarity and consistency of the policy message were the highest-ranked sub-criteria, while budget availability was among the lowest. These results show that the participating stakeholders perceived message quality, technical competence, and role clarity, rather than a shortage of funds, as the most important implementation factors among those assessed. They express expert judgement about relative priority, not measured effects on environmental outcomes.

Badung Regency carries the heaviest tourism load in Indonesia, and with it some of the most serious environmental pressures at the destination scale. These include coastal solid waste, the conversion of agricultural land, and an exceedance of environmental carrying capacity that has not yet been measured. The problems have continued even after Regulation No. 9 of 2021 on Sustainable Tourism Destinations came into force, which suggests that the difficulty lies in how the policy is delivered rather than in the rules themselves. In this study we assessed how the regulation is implemented across its four sustainability pillars and measured the relative importance of the factors that govern delivery. A descriptive qualitative design was combined with the Analytic Hierarchy Process. The qualitative work used in-depth interviews with nine key informants, non-participant observation at Kuta and Seminyak beaches, and documentary analysis, while the Analytic Hierarchy Process broke the four Edwards III determinants into thirteen sub-criteria that were compared on the Saaty ninepoint scale and tested for consistency. Implementation was strongest in the socio-cultural and economic pillars and weakest in the environmental and governance pillars. The Analytic Hierarchy Process ranked communication first (0.399), followed by resources (0.266), bureaucratic structure (0.204), and disposition (0.131), with all consistency ratios below 0.10. Clarity and consistency of the policy message were the highest-ranked sub-criteria, while budget availability was among the lowest. These results show that the participating stakeholders perceived message quality, technical competence, and role clarity, rather than a shortage of funds, as the most important implementation factors among those assessed. They express expert judgement about relative priority, not measured effects on environmental outcomes.

AuthorsAlfi Haris Wanto, Thavia Aisyah Shinta Aprilla, Bambang Santoso Haryono, Eko Nurhaji Purnomo and Akhmad Amirudin
DOI10.46488/NEPT.2027.v26i01.D1969
IssueVol 25, No 4, Oct 2026
VolumeVol 25
PDFOpen PDF in new tab

View Full Paper